Skip to content

checklist.md

Latest commit

 

History

History
1026 lines (776 loc) · 22.8 KB

checklist.md

File metadata and controls

1026 lines (776 loc) · 22.8 KB

📋 Comprehensive Gap Analysis: What Remains

Overview

Current Status: ~40% complete with 3 production-ready components (JS runtime, Webview, Python runtime with CGO)

Major Gaps: 8 language runtimes are stubs, Phase 4 infrastructure is mocked, CLI needs work

🔧 1. CLI Tool (Currently: ~40% Complete)

What Exists

  • Basic command structure (init, build, dev, test, version)
  • Simple project scaffolding
  • File generation for basic projects

What's Missing

1.1 Project Initialization

Current: Creates basic directory structure with template files
Needed:

  • Interactive project wizard (language selection, template choice)
  • Multiple project templates (web app, CLI tool, system utility)
  • Dependency detection and installation guidance
  • Configuration file generation (polyglot.config.json or similar)
  • Git initialization with .gitignore
  • README generation with project-specific info

Estimated Effort: 2-3 weeks

1.2 Build System Integration

Current: Simple go build wrapper
Needed:

  • Intelligent runtime detection (auto-enable based on imports)
  • Build tag management (automatically add -tags for enabled runtimes)
  • Platform-specific builds (handle WebKitGTK on Linux, WebView2 on Windows)
  • Dependency checking (verify Python headers, WebKitGTK, etc.)
  • Build caching to speed up incremental builds
  • Cross-compilation support (polyglot build --platform darwin --arch arm64)
  • Binary optimization (strip symbols, compress, etc.)
  • Asset bundling (embed frontend files)

Estimated Effort: 3-4 weeks

1.3 Development Mode

Current: Just calls build
Needed:

  • Real hot reload for Go code (restart on changes)
  • Frontend hot reload (inject changes without restart)
  • Python module reloading (reimport on change)
  • JavaScript context refresh
  • File watching with debouncing
  • Error display in terminal with file/line numbers
  • Live log streaming
  • DevTools auto-open option

Estimated Effort: 2-3 weeks

1.4 Testing Integration

Current: Runs go test ./...
Needed:

  • Test discovery across all runtimes
  • Python test runner integration (pytest)
  • JavaScript test runner (if using separate JS tests)
  • Coverage reporting (combined across languages)
  • Benchmark running and comparison
  • CI/CD template generation (GitHub Actions, GitLab CI)

Estimated Effort: 2 weeks

1.5 Package Management

Current: None
Needed:

  • polyglot add <runtime> <package> (install Python pip packages, npm packages, etc.)
  • polyglot remove <runtime> <package>
  • Unified lock file (tracks versions across all runtimes)
  • Dependency resolution
  • Virtual environment management (Python venv, node_modules)
  • Dependency tree visualization
  • Security audit integration

Estimated Effort: 3-4 weeks

1.6 Project Management

Current: None
Needed:

  • polyglot info - show project stats, enabled runtimes, dependencies
  • polyglot doctor - health check, verify all dependencies
  • polyglot upgrade - update polyglot framework itself
  • polyglot clean - clear caches, build artifacts
  • polyglot format - run formatters (gofmt, black, prettier)

Estimated Effort: 1-2 weeks

TOTAL CLI EFFORT: 13-18 weeks (3-4.5 months)

🦀 2. Rust Runtime (Currently: ~10% Complete - Stub Only)

What Exists

  • Interface definition
  • Loader skeleton with dlopen/dlsym CGO code
  • Stub implementation for testing
  • Basic test structure

What's Missing

2.1 Core Runtime Implementation

Needed:

  • Compile Rust to shared library (.so/.dll/.dylib)
  • Dynamic library loading and symbol resolution
  • FFI interface definition (C ABI bridge)
  • Memory management across FFI boundary
  • Error handling and propagation
  • Panic catching and recovery
  • Thread safety guarantees

Estimated Effort: 3-4 weeks

2.2 Build Integration

Needed:

  • Cargo integration (run cargo build from Go)
  • Automatic library path resolution
  • Platform-specific library naming (.so vs .dll vs .dylib)
  • Rust dependency management
  • Build caching
  • Cross-compilation support

Estimated Effort: 2 weeks

2.3 Type Marshaling

Needed:

  • Go → Rust type conversion (integers, strings, structs)
  • Rust → Go type conversion
  • Complex types (Vec, HashMap, Option, Result)
  • Ownership semantics handling
  • Lifetime management
  • Zero-copy optimization where possible

Estimated Effort: 2-3 weeks

2.4 Advanced Features

Needed:

  • Async/await support (Tokio runtime)
  • Callback support (Rust calling Go)
  • Trait object handling
  • Generic function support
  • Macro expansion support (if needed)

Estimated Effort: 3-4 weeks

TOTAL RUST EFFORT: 10-13 weeks (2.5-3 months)

☕ 3. Java Runtime (Currently: ~10% Complete - Stub Only)

What Exists

  • Interface definition
  • Worker pool skeleton
  • Stub implementation
  • Test structure

What's Missing

3.1 JNI Integration

Needed:

  • JVM initialization and lifecycle management
  • JNI CGO bindings
  • Class loading mechanism
  • Method invocation (static and instance)
  • Field access
  • Exception handling and propagation
  • Reference management (local/global refs)

Estimated Effort: 4-5 weeks

3.2 Build System

Needed:

  • Java compilation (javac integration)
  • JAR file generation
  • Classpath management
  • Maven/Gradle integration (optional)
  • Dependency resolution
  • Native library inclusion

Estimated Effort: 2 weeks

3.3 Type Bridge

Needed:

  • Primitive type conversion
  • String handling (Java String ↔ Go string)
  • Array and collection conversions
  • Object serialization
  • Custom type mapping

Estimated Effort: 2-3 weeks

3.4 Performance Optimization

Needed:

  • JIT compilation utilization
  • Method caching
  • Thread pool for JNI operations
  • GC tuning guidance
  • Profiling integration

Estimated Effort: 2 weeks

TOTAL JAVA EFFORT: 10-12 weeks (2.5-3 months)

⚡ 4. C++ Runtime (Currently: ~10% Complete - Stub Only)

What Exists

  • Interface definition
  • Loader with dlopen CGO
  • Stub implementation

What's Missing

4.1 Dynamic Library Loading

Needed:

  • C++ compilation to shared library
  • Symbol resolution and caching
  • Name mangling handling (extern "C")
  • Exception boundary handling
  • RTTI support (if needed)

Estimated Effort: 2-3 weeks

4.2 Build System

Needed:

  • CMake integration
  • Compiler detection (g++, clang++)
  • Include path management
  • Library linking
  • Platform-specific flags
  • C++ standard selection (C++11/14/17/20)

Estimated Effort: 2 weeks

4.3 Memory Management

Needed:

  • RAII integration
  • Smart pointer handling
  • Manual memory cleanup hooks
  • Leak detection
  • Cross-boundary ownership rules

Estimated Effort: 2 weeks

4.4 Advanced Features

Needed:

  • Template instantiation support
  • Virtual function calling
  • Multiple inheritance handling
  • STL container conversion
  • Lambda/function object support

Estimated Effort: 3 weeks

TOTAL C++ EFFORT: 9-10 weeks (2-2.5 months)

🐘 5. PHP Runtime (Currently: ~5% Complete - Stub Only)

What Exists

  • Interface definition
  • Worker pool skeleton
  • Stub implementation

What's Missing

5.1 PHP Embedding

Needed:

  • libphp CGO bindings
  • PHP interpreter initialization
  • Script execution mechanism
  • Request context simulation (SAPI)
  • Output buffering
  • Error capture

Estimated Effort: 3-4 weeks

5.2 Integration

Needed:

  • Composer integration
  • Autoloading support
  • Extension loading
  • INI configuration
  • Session handling (if needed)

Estimated Effort: 2 weeks

5.3 Type Conversion

Needed:

  • PHP array ↔ Go slice/map
  • Object serialization
  • Resource handling
  • NULL/nil handling

Estimated Effort: 1-2 weeks

TOTAL PHP EFFORT: 6-8 weeks (1.5-2 months)

💎 6. Ruby Runtime (Currently: ~5% Complete - Stub Only)

What Exists

  • Interface definition
  • Worker pool skeleton
  • Stub implementation

What's Missing

6.1 Ruby Embedding

Needed:

  • libruby CGO bindings
  • Ruby VM initialization
  • Script evaluation
  • GVL (Global VM Lock) management
  • Require path management

Estimated Effort: 3-4 weeks

6.2 Integration

Needed:

  • Gem integration
  • Bundler support
  • Native extension handling
  • C extension compilation

Estimated Effort: 2 weeks

6.3 Object Bridge

Needed:

  • Ruby object → Go conversion
  • Method calling (with blocks)
  • Symbol/String handling
  • Exception mapping

Estimated Effort: 2 weeks

TOTAL RUBY EFFORT: 7-8 weeks (1.75-2 months)

🌙 7. Lua Runtime (Currently: ~5% Complete - Stub Only)

What Exists

  • Interface definition
  • State management skeleton
  • Stub implementation

What's Missing

7.1 Lua Embedding

Needed:

  • Lua C API CGO bindings
  • State creation and management
  • Script execution
  • Stack manipulation utilities
  • Garbage collection integration

Estimated Effort: 2-3 weeks

7.2 Module System

Needed:

  • LuaRocks integration
  • Package path management
  • C module loading
  • Custom module registration

Estimated Effort: 1 week

7.3 Type Bridge

Needed:

  • Table ↔ Map/Slice conversion
  • Userdata for Go objects
  • Metatable handling
  • Coroutine support (optional)

Estimated Effort: 1-2 weeks

TOTAL LUA EFFORT: 4-6 weeks (1-1.5 months)

⚡ 8. Zig Runtime (Currently: ~10% Complete - Stub Only)

What Exists

  • Interface definition
  • Loader skeleton
  • Stub implementation

What's Missing

8.1 Zig Integration

Needed:

  • Zig compilation to shared library
  • C ABI integration
  • Build system integration (zig build)
  • Cross-compilation support

Estimated Effort: 2-3 weeks

8.2 FFI Bridge

Needed:

  • Type conversion (Zig ↔ Go)
  • Error union handling
  • Optional type support
  • Slice/array conversion
  • Struct packing alignment

Estimated Effort: 2 weeks

8.3 Advanced Features

Needed:

  • Comptime execution support
  • Generic function instantiation
  • Async/await integration

Estimated Effort: 2 weeks

TOTAL ZIG EFFORT: 6-7 weeks (1.5-1.75 months)

🕸️ 9. WebAssembly Runtime (Currently: ~5% Complete - Stub Only)

What Exists

  • Interface definition
  • Engine skeleton
  • Stub implementation

What's Missing

9.1 WASM Runtime

Needed:

  • WASM bytecode parser
  • Interpreter or JIT compiler
  • Memory model implementation
  • Import/export handling
  • Table and function references

Estimated Effort: 6-8 weeks (or use existing library like Wasmer/Wasmtime)

9.2 WASI Support

Needed:

  • WASI system calls
  • File system abstraction
  • Environment variables
  • Standard I/O

Estimated Effort: 2-3 weeks

9.3 Integration

Needed:

  • Module loading
  • Instantiation
  • Function calling
  • Memory sharing

Estimated Effort: 2 weeks

TOTAL WASM EFFORT: 10-13 weeks (2.5-3 months) if building from scratch
OR: 2-3 weeks if using existing library

🐹 10. Go Runtime (Interpreter) (Currently: ~5% Complete - Stub Only)

What Exists

  • Interface definition
  • Stub implementation
  • Dependency on yaegi interpreter already in go.mod

What's Missing

10.1 Interpreter Integration

Needed:

  • Yaegi interpreter setup
  • Code execution
  • Import system
  • Standard library access
  • Symbol export/import

Estimated Effort: 2-3 weeks

10.2 Package Management

Needed:

  • Go module support
  • Dependency resolution
  • Build cache integration

Estimated Effort: 1-2 weeks

TOTAL GO RUNTIME EFFORT: 3-5 weeks (0.75-1.25 months)

🔧 11. Build System Enhancements (Currently: ~50% Complete)

What Exists

  • Build tags for selective compilation
  • Basic Go build integration
  • Stub fallback system

What's Missing

11.1 Automated Runtime Detection

Needed:

  • Scan code for runtime imports
  • Auto-enable build tags
  • Dependency verification
  • Platform-specific handling
  • Error messages for missing dependencies

Estimated Effort: 2 weeks

11.2 Cross-Compilation

Needed:

  • Target platform selection
  • Cross-compiler setup (for CGO)
  • Platform-specific library bundling
  • Automated testing on target platforms
  • Docker-based builds for consistent environments

Estimated Effort: 3-4 weeks

11.3 Optimization

Needed:

  • Dead code elimination
  • Binary size optimization (UPX, strip)
  • Runtime selection at build time (only include used runtimes)
  • Asset compression and embedding
  • Build parallelization

Estimated Effort: 2 weeks

TOTAL BUILD SYSTEM EFFORT: 7-8 weeks (1.75-2 months)

🔄 12. Hot Module Replacement (Currently: ~30% Complete)

What Exists

  • File watching with fsnotify
  • Basic reload hooks
  • Interface definition

What's Missing

12.1 Runtime-Specific Reload

Needed:

  • Python module reloading (importlib.reload)
  • JavaScript context refresh
  • Go code hot swap (challenging - may need process restart)
  • State preservation across reloads
  • Connection management (WebSocket for frontend)

Estimated Effort: 3-4 weeks

12.2 Smart Reloading

Needed:

  • Dependency graph analysis
  • Minimal reload scope
  • Error recovery (rollback on failure)
  • State serialization/deserialization
  • Reload confirmation/testing

Estimated Effort: 2-3 weeks

TOTAL HMR EFFORT: 5-7 weeks (1.25-1.75 months)

📊 13. Profiler (Currently: ~20% Complete - Mock Metrics)

What Exists

  • Profiler interface
  • Basic metric tracking structure
  • Mock implementation

What's Missing

13.1 Real Performance Tracking

Needed:

  • CPU profiling per runtime
  • Memory profiling per runtime
  • Function-level timing
  • Call graph generation
  • Flame graph generation
  • Cross-runtime call tracking

Estimated Effort: 3-4 weeks

13.2 Integration

Needed:

  • pprof integration for Go
  • cProfile integration for Python
  • V8 profiler integration for JavaScript
  • Unified output format
  • Web-based visualization
  • Export to standard formats (JSON, protobuf)

Estimated Effort: 2-3 weeks

TOTAL PROFILER EFFORT: 5-7 weeks (1.25-1.75 months)

🔒 14. Security Sandboxing (Currently: ~15% Complete - Interface Only)

What Exists

  • Policy interface
  • Sandbox interface
  • Platform-specific enforcer skeletons

What's Missing

14.1 Linux (Landlock)

Needed:

  • Landlock LSM integration
  • File system restrictions
  • Network restrictions
  • System call filtering (seccomp-bpf)
  • Capability dropping

Estimated Effort: 3-4 weeks

14.2 macOS (App Sandbox)

Needed:

  • Entitlements configuration
  • Container directory setup
  • Powerbox for file access
  • Network restrictions

Estimated Effort: 2-3 weeks

14.3 Windows (AppContainer)

Needed:

  • AppContainer creation
  • Capability configuration
  • Named object isolation
  • Lowbox token setup

Estimated Effort: 3-4 weeks

14.4 Runtime-Specific Sandboxing

Needed:

  • Python module import restrictions
  • JavaScript eval restrictions
  • File system access control per runtime
  • Network access control per runtime

Estimated Effort: 2 weeks

TOTAL SECURITY EFFORT: 10-13 weeks (2.5-3 months)

🛍️ 15. Marketplace (Currently: ~5% Complete - Mock Only)

What Exists

  • Interface definitions
  • Mock registry
  • Mock client
  • Basic cache implementation

What's Missing

15.1 Registry Backend

Needed:

  • Database design (PostgreSQL/MongoDB)
  • REST API server
  • Package upload system
  • Version management
  • Search functionality (Elasticsearch?)
  • User authentication
  • Rating/review system

Estimated Effort: 6-8 weeks

15.2 Package Format

Needed:

  • Package specification (manifest format)
  • Dependency resolution algorithm
  • Package validation
  • Security scanning
  • License compliance checking
  • Digital signatures

Estimated Effort: 3-4 weeks

15.3 Client Implementation

Needed:

  • HTTP client for registry API
  • Download with progress
  • Signature verification
  • Installation process
  • Conflict resolution
  • Rollback capability

Estimated Effort: 3 weeks

15.4 Template System

Needed:

  • Template format specification
  • Variable substitution
  • File generation
  • Template validation
  • Template marketplace

Estimated Effort: 2-3 weeks

TOTAL MARKETPLACE EFFORT: 14-18 weeks (3.5-4.5 months)

☁️ 16. Cloud Services (Currently: ~5% Complete - Mock Only)

What Exists

  • Interface definitions
  • Mock client
  • Mock builder
  • Mock storage

What's Missing

16.1 Build Infrastructure

Needed:

  • Build server implementation
  • Container orchestration (Docker/K8s)
  • Build queue management
  • Platform-specific build environments
  • Build caching
  • Artifact storage (S3/GCS)
  • Build logs and status

Estimated Effort: 8-10 weeks

16.2 Authentication System

Needed:

  • User registration/login
  • API key management
  • OAuth integration
  • Team/organization support
  • Permission system

Estimated Effort: 4-5 weeks

16.3 Storage System

Needed:

  • Artifact storage (S3-compatible)
  • CDN integration
  • Version management
  • Retention policies
  • Access control

Estimated Effort: 3-4 weeks

16.4 API Implementation

Needed:

  • REST/gRPC API
  • WebSocket for real-time updates
  • Rate limiting
  • Usage tracking
  • Billing integration

Estimated Effort: 4-5 weeks

TOTAL CLOUD EFFORT: 19-24 weeks (4.75-6 months)

🔏 17. Code Signing (Currently: ~5% Complete - Stubs Only)

What Exists

  • Interface definitions
  • Platform-specific stubs

What's Missing

17.1 macOS Signing

Needed:

  • codesign integration
  • Certificate management
  • Notarization support (notarytool)
  • Entitlements handling
  • Universal binary signing
  • DMG creation and signing

Estimated Effort: 2-3 weeks

17.2 Windows Signing

Needed:

  • SignTool integration
  • Certificate storage (Azure Key Vault)
  • Authenticode signing
  • MSI/MSIX packaging
  • Installer signing

Estimated Effort: 2-3 weeks

17.3 Linux Signing

Needed:

  • GPG signing
  • AppImage signing
  • DEB/RPM signing
  • Flatpak/Snap signing

Estimated Effort: 2 weeks

TOTAL SIGNING EFFORT: 6-8 weeks (1.5-2 months)

🔄 18. Update System (Currently: ~5% Complete - Mock Only)

What Exists

  • Interface definitions
  • Mock diff/patch
  • Mock downloader
  • Mock verifier

What's Missing

18.1 Differential Updates

Needed:

  • Binary diffing algorithm (bsdiff/courgette)
  • Patch generation
  • Patch application
  • Compression (zstd/brotli)
  • Delta testing

Estimated Effort: 3-4 weeks

18.2 Update Client

Needed:

  • Update checking
  • Background downloading
  • Progress UI
  • Signature verification
  • Rollback on failure
  • A/B testing support

Estimated Effort: 3-4 weeks

18.3 Update Server

Needed:

  • Update manifest generation
  • Version management
  • Staged rollouts
  • Analytics integration
  • Rollback management

Estimated Effort: 3-4 weeks

TOTAL UPDATE EFFORT: 9-12 weeks (2.25-3 months)

📚 19. Documentation (Currently: ~60% Complete)

What Exists

  • README files for components
  • Build guides
  • Example READMEs
  • CONTRIBUTING.md

What's Missing

19.1 User Documentation

Needed:

  • Getting started guide
  • Tutorial series (beginner to advanced)
  • API reference (auto-generated from code)
  • Best practices guide
  • Performance tuning guide
  • Troubleshooting guide
  • FAQ

Estimated Effort: 4-5 weeks

19.2 Developer Documentation

Needed:

  • Architecture deep dive
  • Runtime implementation guide
  • Contributing guide enhancement
  • Code style guide
  • Testing guide
  • Release process

Estimated Effort: 2-3 weeks

19.3 Examples

Needed:

  • Simple counter app (exists)
  • Todo app with persistence
  • Real-time chat app
  • Data visualization app
  • System utility (file manager, etc.)
  • Game (simple, demonstrate performance)
  • ML inference app (Python + UI)

Estimated Effort: 4-6 weeks

TOTAL DOCUMENTATION EFFORT: 10-14 weeks (2.5-3.5 months)

🎨 20. Examples & Demos (Currently: ~30% Complete)

What Exists

  • hello-world (basic)
  • webview-demo (good)

What's Missing

20.1 More Example Apps

Needed:

  • Multi-language demo (Python + JS + Go together)
  • Real-world app (text editor, image viewer, etc.)
  • Performance demo (showing benchmarks)
  • Cross-platform demo (showing platform differences)

Estimated Effort: 3-4 weeks

20.2 Video Demos

Needed:

  • Getting started video
  • Building an app walkthrough
  • Performance comparison
  • Feature showcase

Estimated Effort: 1-2 weeks

TOTAL EXAMPLES EFFORT: 4-6 weeks (1-1.5 months)

📊 SUMMARY: Total Remaining Effort

Category Effort (weeks) Priority
CLI Tool 13-18 🔴 High
Rust Runtime 10-13 🟡 Medium
Java Runtime 10-12 🟢 Low
C++ Runtime 9-10 🟡 Medium
PHP Runtime 6-8 🟢 Low
Ruby Runtime 7-8 🟢 Low
Lua Runtime 4-6 🟡 Medium
Zig Runtime 6-7 🟡 Medium
WASM Runtime 2-3 (library) 🟡 Medium
Go Runtime 3-5 🟢 Low
Build System 7-8 🔴 High
HMR 5-7 🟡 Medium
Profiler 5-7 🟡 Medium
Security 10-13 🟡 Medium
Marketplace 14-18 🟢 Low
Cloud Services 19-24 🟢 Low
Code Signing 6-8 🟡 Medium
Update System 9-12 🟡 Medium
Documentation 10-14 🔴 High
Examples 4-6 🔴 High

🎯 Recommended Priority Path

Phase A: Polish Core (16-24 weeks)

  1. CLI Tool completion (13-18 weeks)
  2. Documentation expansion (10-14 weeks)
  3. More examples (4-6 weeks)
  4. Build system enhancement (7-8 weeks)

Parallel work possible: 12-18 weeks with good planning

Phase B: Add One Language (10-13 weeks)

Pick ONE of:

  • Rust (10-13 weeks) - Best choice for performance
  • C++ (9-10 weeks) - Good for existing libraries
  • Lua (4-6 weeks) - Fastest to complete

Phase C: Infrastructure (20-30 weeks)

  • HMR (5-7 weeks)
  • Profiler (5-7 weeks)
  • Security (10-13 weeks)
  • Code signing (6-8 weeks)

Phase D: Platform Features (Optional, 40-50 weeks)

  • Marketplace (14-18 weeks)
  • Cloud services (19-24 weeks)
  • Update system (9-12 weeks)

🚀 Realistic Roadmap

Milestone Duration Cumulative % Complete
Today - - 40%
+ Phase A 4 months 4 months 60%
+ Phase B 3 months 7 months 70%
+ Phase C 6 months 13 months 85%
+ Phase D 12 months 25 months 100%

Minimum Viable Product (MVP): Phase A + Phase B = 7 months
Production Ready v1.0: Phase A + B + C = 13 months
Feature Complete: All phases = 25 months

Key Insight: You have ~40% done. The remaining 60% breaks down as:

  • 20% = Core polish (CLI, docs, build system) - Critical
  • 15% = One more runtime - Important
  • 25% = Infrastructure (HMR, profiler, security, signing, updates) - Nice to have
  • 40% = Platform services (marketplace, cloud) - Optional

Focus on the first 35% (20% + 15%) to reach 75% and have a truly competitive product.