Skip to content

apply hidden API policy after exec spawning + pass disabled compat changes through exec spawning #359

Open
inthewaves wants to merge 2 commits into
GrapheneOS:16-qpr2from
inthewaves:exec-spawn-fixes
Open

apply hidden API policy after exec spawning + pass disabled compat changes through exec spawning #359
inthewaves wants to merge 2 commits into
GrapheneOS:16-qpr2from
inthewaves:exec-spawn-fixes

Conversation

@inthewaves

@inthewaves inthewaves commented Jun 1, 2026

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Member

Changeset:

Closes GrapheneOS/os-issue-tracker#7899

Exec-spawned app processes do not run the normal zygote post-fork hook that applies hidden API and test API policy from runtime flags. This change calls ZygoteHooks.postExecSpawn(int) from ExecInit after normalizing exec-spawned runtime mappings and before resolving the app entrypoint, so policy is applied before app code is loaded. This fixes the stack overflow crash from GrapheneOS/os-issue-tracker#7899, since the lack of hidden API enforcement introduced a cycle in the recursive reflection dump code in the app:

Object
-> shadow$_klass_ (should've been blocked by hidden API policy)
-> Class.classLoader
-> PathClassLoader.pathList
-> DexPathList.definingContext
-> same PathClassLoader

Also, dropping the disabled compat change list before RuntimeInit.applicationInit. made ART treat ALLOW_TEST_API_ACCESS as enabled even when framework compat had disabled it for the package.

Carry parsed disabled compat changes through ExecInit so exec spawned apps get the same compat state as the zygote fork path.

  • Test: atest GosCompatSecureSpawnTests
  • Test: atest CtsHiddenApiBlocklistCurrentApiTestCases CtsHiddenApiBlocklistTestApiTestCases (both with exec spawning on, then re-running both tests after turning off exec spawning + reboot). Without this changeset, these tests were failing with exec spawning on but passing with it off

Exec-spawned app processes do not run the normal zygote post-fork hook that applies hidden API and
test API policy from runtime flags. This change calls ZygoteHooks.postExecSpawn(int) from ExecInit
after normalizing exec-spawned runtime mappings and before resolving the app entrypoint, so policy
is applied before app code is loaded.

Requires the corresponding changes to art and libcore

Test: atest GosSecureSpawnTests:SecureSpawnEnabledHostTest#{acyclicReflectiveDumpCheck,hiddenApiEnforcementCheck}
Dropping the disabled compat change list before RuntimeInit.applicationInit.
made ART treat ALLOW_TEST_API_ACCESS as enabled even when framework compat
had disabled it for the package.

Carry parsed disabled compat changes through ExecInit so exec spawned apps get
the same compat state as the zygote fork path.

Test: atest GosCompatSecureSpawnTests:SecureSpawnEnabledHostTest#testApiCompatDefaultCheck
Test: atest CtsHiddenApiBlocklistCurrentApiTestCases CtsHiddenApiBlocklistTestApiTestCases
      (both with exec spawning on, then re-running both tests after turning off exec
      spawning + reboot)
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

Secure spawning compatibility issue with Nikon Snapbridge app

1 participant